A Constitutional Crisis in Plain Sight: Trump Defies Supreme Court Over Wrongful Deportation

Welp, we’re here.

When the Supreme Court of the United States speaks, the nation is supposed to listen—especially the president. That’s how the checks and balances of our fragile democracy are designed to work. But this past week, Donald Trump, with the full-throated support of Senator Marco Rubio, looked at the highest court in the land and effectively said: No.

Let’s break down what just happened—because it’s chilling.

---

Kilmar Armando Abrego García, a legal Maryland resident, was mistakenly deported to El Salvador last month. He was under protection due to credible threats of gang violence, and his removal from the country was not just a bureaucratic blunder—it was a violation of his rights and U.S. law.

On April 10, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously ruled that his deportation was unlawful. In its decision, the Court ordered the federal government to “facilitate” Abrego García’s return and restore him to the legal position he would’ve held had he not been deported.

But instead of complying, Trump did what Trump does best: defied precedent, decency, and the Constitution. In a joint appearance with Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele, Trump thanked him for “his strength” and said the U.S. would “respect El Salvador’s sovereignty”—a diplomatic euphemism for flipping the bird to the Supreme Court.

---

El Salvadoran President Bukele and President Trump

Bukele declared he will not return Abrego García to the U.S. Trump and Rubio responded not with outrage or diplomatic pressure, but with approval. They’ve essentially decided that the Supreme Court’s orders are optional—when it suits them.

This is a constitutional crisis. It is not hypothetical. It is not theoretical. It is not future-tense. It is happening right now.

When the Executive Branch refuses to carry out a lawful order from the Judicial Branch, the rule of law collapses. The idea that the courts can serve as a check on authoritarian power? Gone. The notion that U.S. citizens have protections under the Constitution? Hanging by a thread.

If the president can ignore the courts and openly collude with a foreign leader to deny justice to a resident of this country—what can’t he do?

And don’t let the silence fool you. Many in the Republican Party are quietly thrilled. This isn’t just about Kilmar Abrego García anymore. It’s about power—who gets to wield it, and who gets to be crushed beneath it.

We should all be horrified. But horror alone isn’t enough. This moment demands protest, pressure, and a full-throated defense of the very principles that underpin American democracy.

If Trump gets away with this, the Supreme Court might still wear its robes—but it’ll be nothing more than theater. The law only matters if those in power agree to be bound by it.

Right now, they’re not.

---

A note from #TeamFAFO

FAFO Newscast was created with a purpose: to tell the truth loudly and to make sure the stories mainstream media won’t touch still get told. We’re living in a time when too many newsrooms have been sanitized, compromised, or outright silenced out of fear of Donald Trump and the extremist movement he’s empowered. The result? Censorship by cowardice—and a public left in the dark.

Not here. Not ever.

We don’t flinch. We don’t sugarcoat. We don’t play respectability politics with oppression.

We want to keep most of our content free and accessible—to make sure that no one is priced out of the truth. Independent media at Substack is a movement like no other, and we are so glad to be on this journey with all of you!

But to keep this movement going and growing, we need your help.

We’re expanding. Our team is growing to include contributors from Australia and the UK. We’re about to launch the FAFO podcast, and that means new mics, editing gear, and production support. Everything we do is grassroots and community-powered.

So if you’ve appreciated what we’re building, please consider supporting us in one of these ways:

• Buy us a coffee with a one-time donation: https://buymeacoffee.com/fafonewscast

• Become a paid subscriber: $5/month or $50/year.
  That’s less than the price of a fast-food meal—but it helps us keep serving truth without compromise.

Together, we can build the kind of media that doesn’t just report the news—but moves people to action.

Thank you again for supporting independent journalism. We’re just getting started.

With Love & Fire,

#TeamFAFO

---